TenantCloud vs RentRedi 2026: Honest Side-by-Side

TenantCloud is a cheap PM-style suite with a free tier that's genuinely usable for 1–5 doors. RentRedi is a mobile-first landlord tool with a flat monthly subscription, credit-bureau reporting for rent, and TransUnion screening. Past 25 doors, both start hitting walls — TenantCloud on accounting depth, RentRedi on the lack of a real PM accounting layer at all.

This is a comparison between two products that look similar in marketing and feel very different in daily use. The pick depends on whether you want a landlord tool or a thin PM suite — different categories with overlapping pricing.

TL;DR verdict

• Choose TenantCloud if: you have 1–25 doors, you want a low-cost suite covering leasing, payments, light accounting, and owner reporting, and you can tolerate UI rough edges.
• Choose RentRedi if: you're a landlord with 1–20 units, you live on mobile, you want rent payments to build tenant credit, and you're fine doing accounting outside the tool.
• Choose neither if: you're 25+ doors managing for other owners — neither has the trust-account discipline, custom owner reporting, or audit-ready accounting a third-party PM needs.

Pricing structure

TenantCloud is tiered, with a free starter tier and per-unit-ish paid tiers. RentRedi is a flat monthly subscription regardless of door count, with separate per-transaction fees.

What you actually pay:

• TenantCloud free tier: $0 base, real limits on tenants and features. Workable for 1–3 doors.
• TenantCloud paid tiers at 10–25 doors: typically $50–$200/mo all-in.
• RentRedi: roughly $10–$20/mo on an annual plan regardless of door count, plus transaction fees. The math gets very attractive as door count rises — and that's where it also runs out of road on the accounting side.

Features that actually matter

Accounting

• TenantCloud: Income/expense tracking, basic owner accounting on higher tiers, IRS-friendly Schedule E reporting. It is not Buildium-grade, but it tries.
• RentRedi: Income tracking, expense tracking, basic reports. No owner draws, no holdbacks, no real PM accounting. REI Hub integration covers double-entry books for an extra fee.

Edge: TenantCloud if you need anything that looks like property accounting in-product.

Tenant experience

• TenantCloud: Functional portal, mobile app, AutoPay. UI is dated in places.
• RentRedi: Mobile-first, polished tenant app, AutoPay, in-app maintenance with photos. Strong.

Edge: RentRedi.

Leasing

• TenantCloud: Listing syndication, applicant pipeline, eSign, screening. The full landlord-suite shape.
• RentRedi: Marketing, prospect tracking, screening (TransUnion), eSign. Lighter on listing distribution than TenantCloud.

Edge: TenantCloud for syndication reach, Tie for screening outcomes.

Maintenance

• TenantCloud: Work-order intake, vendor tracking, status updates.
• RentRedi: Tenant-submitted requests with photos and videos. Vendor coordination is manual.

Edge: TenantCloud.

Credit reporting and tenant retention

• TenantCloud: Available as a paid add-on.
• RentRedi: Included with the subscription. This is a real tenant-retention lever in competitive markets.

Edge: RentRedi.

Owner reporting

• TenantCloud: Owner portal and statements on higher tiers. Functional for small portfolios with a handful of owners.
• RentRedi: No real concept of "owner" separate from "landlord." Not a PM tool in that sense.

Edge: TenantCloud, the moment you have an owner to report to.

What both don't tell you

• TenantCloud's free tier shrinks the more you use it. The limit you hit first is usually the paid feature for templates, more tenants, or owner reporting. Useful as a starting point; rarely a long-term home past 5–10 units.
• RentRedi looks cheap because the subscription is flat. It is genuinely cheap. The hidden cost is everything that isn't in the product — owner reporting, trust accounting, custom reports — which you build on top in QuickBooks or REI Hub. That stack is fine; just count it.
• Neither is ready for state PM licensing trust-account requirements. If you manage other people's units in a state with broker-license trust-account rules, validate the workflow with your broker before committing.
• TenantCloud's UI is a known friction point. It's not unusable, but it's the most-mentioned complaint in operator threads. Try the free tier before signing a paid one.
• RentRedi mobile-first means desktop is the weaker experience. If your daily workflow lives on a laptop, factor that in.

Decision matrix

When either of these stops scaling — usually somewhere in the 20–40 door range, depending on how much accounting and owner reporting you need — the next step is a real PM-grade platform. Flat-priced options exist in that category, including Proprietio, which is built for mixed portfolios without per-door fees.

FAQ

Is TenantCloud really free? The starter tier is free with real feature and tenant limits. Most operators upgrade within a few months as they hit ceilings.

Does RentRedi's credit reporting cost extra? It's included with the subscription. Tenants who pay rent through RentRedi can opt to have on-time rent reported to TransUnion — a tenant-acquisition advantage worth quantifying.

Which one handles owner accounting? TenantCloud has a basic owner module on paid tiers. RentRedi does not.

Can I migrate between them? Yes, but plan for manual cleanup. Both export CSVs of tenants, leases, and payment history. Document storage is the bit that travels less cleanly.

---

Run mixed portfolios? Try Proprietio free for 15 days — residential, condo, and commercial in one workspace, no per-door fees. proprietio.com